Response to Economic Stimuli ? Market Fall ?
We are all excited about the 200,000,00,000,000 package
announced by Prime Minister Modi and are trying to find its possible and
plausible impact on our lives. If we try to do the math the figure comes out of
be roughly 10% of our Gross domestic product (GDP).
It would be very interesting to know what it comprises of or
what things contribute, who contributes to it and where do we stand.
Sector
|
Contribution
|
Primary
|
16.00%
|
Secondary
|
29.00%
|
Tertiary
|
55.00%
|
To
simplify Primary is Agriculture based and allied business, Secondary is
Manufacturing and tertiary is the
Service sector.
Stock markets initially rallied from the bottom created by
end of March almost falling 38 % from the peak and by April we saw almost an
unreal rally which recouped almost half of the lost ground and now the stimulus
package is here markets response to stimuli was that of a shock.
I had to recount the number of zeros, still unsure if I
missed one in this 20 trillion rupee figure, sure this looks massive a look at
its break up and how much have we done to save the economy versus the globe.
Ok so India's GDP and
most importantly per capita GDP is not comparable on an absolute basis the
numbers don't look small by any stretch of imagination. Let's have a look at
them in the table below.
![]() |
GDP Ratings |
I have taken data from the IMF website as you shall find
varying data from all sources, if we
rank countries by nominal GDP in absolute terms we are amongst the so called as
fantastic five and we proudly can pump
our fist but the moment we take our population in count we realise we
hardly make a cut amongst the top 150 nations ( 144 rank). So agreed we have
problem of plenty and we are or less
cognizant of the same and unlike our bigger communist counterpart we are not
forcing issue of one child/ two child policy. Keeping this context must say
it's a bold move. And i don't give that deal of priority to stimulus as much as
the reforms the so called as process of removal of impediments in economic
growth.
Now the so called as
LLL/Labour, Land& Legal reforms can be a second turning point in her growth
story. Last was in 1991 when Dr. Manmohan Singh gave the historic speech
and we are what we are where we are due to his moves on LPG /Liberalization,
Privatisation and Globalisation. Mind you very well as genius as it may sound
it was not a proactive visionary move, it was very much forced upon when we had
the Balance of payment crisis. So let's
accept we are like that kid who always chills for better part of the year and when grey clouds of semester exams loom
large and there is no way out he opens the book. This time around its not
much different, we have made the move of big bang reforms only when we are
pitted against the wall. Now the million dollar question why is market
reacting the way it is ?
The devil lies in the detail. If you look at the stimulus
from where the Govt is going to fund this amount ? If you look at major part of the stimulus has
to be funded by borrowing. Now it's estimated that a borrowing in excess of INR12,000,000,000,000 ( 12 lac Cr) will be needed to plug the Gap.
Most of it is going to come from borrowings. Which means
India's Debt to GDP will sky rocket, on account of piling of new debt and fall
in overall economic .
Which may put bond yields under pressure and there is a fear
that India's sovereign rating might be under threat of being downgraded.
All these factors make the market nervous in Short term.
Well in short term it's never behaved rationally, so makes it impossible to
predict. Successful traders tend to react and chase momentum/trend rather than
pre-empt the market. Well there is no denying the Labour and Land reforms will transform the landscape and
we shall be the new destination who might just steal a part of thunder from
China.
And I choose my words carefully, what China has achieved in
last decade has been impeccable to replicate that will take lot of dogged
determination and statesmanship from our leaders and sheer obsession to achieve
by our entrepreneurs.
All in all these are exciting times we live in and coming
decade shall for sure be better than the previous ones.
Excellent rendition of the ecconomic stimulus package & the understanding the effect of the same. India has a golden opportunity to take advantage of this crisis. The markets will fall in line in due course if this pandamic doesn't stretch too long.
ReplyDeleteAgreed ... India can really make the next two decades its own..the per capita GDP can move from. 2.4K to 10K
DeleteVery Informative & well studied article
ReplyDeleteThanks !
Delete